LIBERTY HEIGHTS (1999)

Fictional Date: Fall 1954
Score: 

Following the Kurtzman family through one year, from Rosh Hashanah (the Jewish New Year in the fall) to Rosh Hashanah, this embarrassing mess loses the thread on every level. Joe Mantegna, miscast as patriarch Nate, is a cheap crook and burlesque house owner who also runs numbers and is heading for the inevitable comeuppance. Older son Van is obsessed with an alcoholic shiksa (gentile girl) that he met at a party, who later turns up as the second blonde in the series to ride in on a horse and steal someone’s heart. Younger son Ben, the narrative voice of the movie, develops a close friendship with Sylvia, a black girl at school, yielding some of the film’s only warm moments and a look at how the changing landscape of residential Baltimore brought different cultures together in the mid-’50s.
This is not as profoundly drawn a change in Baltimore life as that which transformed the family unit in AVALON, and for the most part LIBERTY HEIGHTS gives us a series of disjointed sequences that reinforce disgusting stereotypes on both sides. This is just a parade of none-too-appealing characters, and it almost seems as if a non-Jewish outsider with no emotional connection to the material wrote this one instead of the Barry Levinson of the previous three movies. The interracial relationship is even transparently lifted from the far superior A BRONX TALE!
There are also some missed opportunities among a few minor gems. Although we meet some real Baltimoreans like Asian student Ping Der (my mother actually knew her), we never see any of the DINER guys or peripheral characters, even though the younger kids in this movie are roughly contemporary with them. There are of course the requisite diner conversation scenes (and even a similar mirror shot at one point), and again these are the only times when the film’s dialogue comes alive and threatens to entertain.
Otherwise it’s uncomfortable to watch at times, contrived (as with the sudden convenient paralysis of Trey), and very insulting to both the Jewish characters (who come off as underhanded swindlers) and the African-American characters as well (Orlando Jones, despite turning in a solid performance with what he’s been given, is just a two-bit patsy).
A few historical touches (the looming shadow of the Maryland lottery, the decline of the old Block before the modern adult theaters moved in) aren’t enough to give LIBERTY HEIGHTS as much “oomph” as the rest of the series, and the attempts at emotional resonance ring hollow.
In the final moments, Ben says that a relative of his once said “If I knew things would no longer be, I would have remembered better.” This is a direct quote from Sam’s final scene in AVALON, either suggesting that the Kurtzman family is linked to the Krichinskys of the previous movie, or that Levinson was desperately hoping to feed off that film’s strong sense of heart.
In the end, LIBERTY HEIGHTS is an overlong misfire from a guy who appeared to have this kind of movie down cold. How a man who grew up Jewish in Baltimore and reflected that experience so warmly and accurately in AVALON could turn around and produce something so skewed and unnecessarily unflattering is a mystery. LIBERTY HEIGHTS portrays unredeemable, sleazy characters in situations that they created for themselves, perpetuating awful stereotypes and adding little to the mythos built up in the previous three movies. While fans of the series might wish to see Levinson shoot another Baltimore film, LIBERTY HEIGHTS almost makes some of us wish that he leave the series alone from now on.
Cars: In one of the more insulting moments, Levinson has crooked patriarch Nate Kurtzman walk out of an Orthodox Rosh Hashanah synagogue service to look at the new Cadillacs at the local dealership, something he evidently does every year! It’s no wonder he has such a lousy fate. But it does show the ultimate power of the Cadillac, that icon of affluence and American success that Levinson celebrated before in such a central way in TIN MEN. Levinson just can’t get enough of that shot of a shiny new Caddy spinning on the display dais, and of course the car figures prominently in the Little Melvin subplot as well.
Music: Also taking center stage here, as Levinson explores the division between black and white Baltimore in the ’50s, is James Brown (or a reasonable facsimile) who performs at the Royal. One wonders if DINER’s Shrevie was in the crowd that night. The usual stripper music heavy on saxophone and soul also crops up in multiple drawn-out (and very boring) sequences set in Nate’s burlesque house, bringing us to Baltimore’s infamous Block repeatedly throughout the film. Sinatra is once again a god among men, and Ben even forces Sylvia’s father to sit in a car with him until Frank finishes a song on the radio. Now that’s commitment.
Baltimore Geography: Besides the aforementioned Block (a section of Baltimore Street famed for its, shall we say, “adult” entertainment), we see Forest Park quite a bit, which is naturally right off Liberty Heights. We return to the Washington Monument, see a streetcar like the one in AVALON that led to a minor disaster, and return to the Druid Hill Conservatory and zoo as in the previous movie. University of Baltimore Law School (remember Boog?) is a big player as Van’s little troupe are all students there.
That Tabakin Touch: Unfortunately, Ralph doesn’t do much here apart from operate the spotlight at Nate’s burlesque house. He whines almost incoherently when Nate orders him to kill the spot on a girl who’s threatening to go nude, thus putting them in danger of being arrested. A waste of Tabakin’s considerable talents, but at least he’s there.
Epilogue: And there we have it, the Baltimore films of Barry Levinson to date. They all have their charm - even LIBERTY HEIGHTS - and DINER is still one of the great viewing experiences of all time. So if you want to feel like you’re spending some quality time in the City That Reads, I suggest you rent the first movie, get some French Fries with gravy, and join Eddie, Billy, Shrevie, Fenwick, Boog and Modell, hon. I’ll see you all later at the diner!
ATB














































































